top of page
Golden City Church - the view from our Church in Golden, Colorado of South Table Mountain

Following Jesus Together

JOIN US

SUNDAYS

@ 4:00 PM

Why Obedience Is Not Legalism

Oct 15
4 min read

Updated: Oct 16



For some Christians, the word obedience carries uncomfortable memories. Many have heard sermons that left us wondering whether we could ever do enough to please God. Others have experienced churches where personal preferences became spiritual requirements, and appearances mattered more than honesty. The concern about legalism deserves to be taken seriously and examined thoughtfully.

 

But those experiences raise an important question: Does rejecting legalism mean we should stop emphasizing obedience?

 

The Bible gives us a healthy path forward, showing that salvation comes before sanctification and acceptance precedes obedience.  God saves us by grace, and that same grace leads us into a transformed life. Obedience flows from our relationship with Jesus.  But legalism distorts that relationship by making our performance the basis of our standing before God.

 

Legalism can be defined as an attempt to earn acceptance with God through religious performance. It can also be described as treating human rules as though they carry God’s authority, then using those rules to measure everyone else’s faithfulness. Neither of these mindsets is the same as humbly responding to God’s commands. 

 

Ephesians 2:8–10 makes the relationship between grace and obedience clear. Paul explains that salvation is God’s gift, received through faith rather than earned through works. Then he says we are created in Christ Jesus for good works.

 

“For by grace you have been saved through faith. And this is not your own doing; it is the gift of God, not a result of works, so that no one may boast. For we are his workmanship, created in Christ Jesus for good works, which God prepared beforehand, that we should walk in them.”

-Ephesians 2:8–10, ESV          

Our good works do not purchase salvation; they flow out of the new life God has given to everyone who has believed the gospel and received Jesus as Lord and Savior. Obedience is the fruit of salvation, not the foundation of our justification.  In Christ, we are declared righteous, holy, forgiven, and free from the power and penalty of sin.  And through Christ, we have the indwelling Spirit, who empowers us to live righteously, doing justice and love mercy. 

 

A person can pray, give, serve, and attend church in an attempt to prove their worth to God. Another person can do those same things as an overflow of faith that trusts Christ and wants to honor him. The outward actions may look similar, but the motive is different. One is rooted in fear, while the other is rooted in faith.  One is self-reliant and can produce a Pharisaical heart, while the other is Spirit-reliant and produces good fruit that reflects Christ and blesses others.

 

Jesus connects obedience with love. In John 14:15, he tells his disciples that loving him leads to keeping his commands. “If you love me, you will keep my commandments.” (ESV) A loving relationship with Jesus includes listening to him, trusting his wisdom, and responding to his authority by obeying His Word. 

That does not mean obedience always feels easy, or that we are enthusiastic about it. Forgiving someone who hurt us, telling the truth when it costs us, or resisting temptation can involve a real struggle. But choosing faithfulness while our feelings tell us otherwise is not automatically legalism. Sometimes choosing obedience is how God shapes our hearts by His love. 

 

Grace does not make obedience unnecessary. Titus 2:11–14 describes grace as teaching us to reject ungodliness and live godly lives. Paul adamantly rejects the idea that we should continue in sin to greater display God’s grace (Romans 6:1–4). The grace that brings salvation is also meant to sanctify our lives towards Christlikeness. 

 

Christian obedience also depends on God’s power. Philippians 2:12–13 calls believers to actively live out their salvation while explaining that God works within them, shaping both their desires and their actions. Our effort matters, and God’s Spirit makes that effort possible.

 

This puts spiritual disciplines into their proper place. Prayer, Scripture reading, worship, sharing our faith, and living in Christian community help us grow in faithfulness. They become distorted when we treat them as a payment that obligates God to bless us or as a scorecard proving our superiority.

 

We must also distinguish God’s commands from our own applications. In Mark 7:6–13, Jesus rebukes religious leaders whose traditions undermine God’s command. In their minds, their religious strictness actually provided a way to avoid caring for their parents, a direct violation of God’s commands. 

 

Today, Christians might wisely establish boundaries around entertainment, technology, or spending. Those boundaries can help them obey God. But it does not automatically become a universal command for every believer. Romans 14 teaches Christians to make room for differing convictions on disputable matters without condemning one another.

Two concerns deserve to be heard. Some Christians emphasize grace because they fear shame, spiritual control, and endless demands. Others emphasize obedience because they fear a version of faith that excuses ongoing sin. Both identify real dangers. Scripture gives us grounds to reject both self-righteousness and indifference to holiness. And all of us can swing between feeling defeated by our failures and becoming proud of our obedience.

In either case, we need to return to the gospel. We cannot work harder to purchase forgiveness, and we should not dismiss our sin as unimportant. Romans 8:1 assures those in Christ that there is no condemnation for them. Hebrews 12:5–11 describes God’s loving discipline, through which he trains his children in holiness. His correction is an expression of his love. Grace frees us to acknowledge our sin, receive his forgiveness, and pursue obedience with humility and dependence on him.

We can therefore confess honestly, receive mercy, repair the harm we have caused, and take the next faithful step.

 

The question is not “Am I doing enough?” Better questions are, “Am I trusting Jesus? Am I listening to what he has commanded? Am I using my obedience to exalt myself, or learning to love God and my neighbor?”

 

Christian obedience grows as we learn to trust the Savior who has already given himself for us. We follow him because his grace has brought us near, his commands are good, and his Spirit is at work within us.

 
 
bottom of page